Basic Requirements of a Freegle Group: Difference between revisions

From Freegle Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
 
(48 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
THIS PAGE HAS BEEN SUPERSEDED BY [[Group Affiliation Requirements Policy]] BUT KEPT HERE AS HISTORICAL REFERENCE


'''Mandatory recommendations:'''


The mandatory affiliation requirements for the Freegle organisation in relation to local groups, were decided in a poll in January  2010:


'''All items offered or requested have to be free.'''
===Affiliation Requirements===


'''All items offered or requested have to be legal.'''
The affiliation requirements for groups to be able to join and be part of the Freegle organisation were decided by polls of Freegle Volunteers.  Now that we are an IPS, any changes will be by poll of Freegle Members.


This means that all of the requirements above are our basic shared values, and should be followed by all groups listed on the Freegle website.
The [[October 2009 Poll]] and [[January 2010 Poll]], plus a Resolution carried at the AGM in 2019 [[https://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/AGM_2019_Minutes]] produced the current set of requirements for groups as follows:


'''Non-mandatory Recommendations:'''
* All items offered or requested have to be free – mandatory
* All items offered or requested have to be legal – mandatory
* Selling of items is not allowed – mandatory
* Be a non-profit group – mandatory
* Swapping is not allowed - mandatory
* Inclusion of the Freegle logo on the homepage- mandatory
* Inclusion of a link to the Freegle website on the homepage - mandatory
* All Freegle Volunteers will receive national announcements - mandatory
* Do not allow messages asking to borrow items – highly recommended
* Operate in a geographical area agreed with Freegle – highly recommended


the below guidelines are 'highly recommended' by Freegle, but not madatory, this is because they didn't receive a high enough majority in the poll.
Polls were held at the AGM 2016 [[http://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/AGM_2016_Minutes#Minutes_of_previous_meeting]], resulting in the following:


'''Do not allow swapping of items'''
*Freegle groups must use at least one "viable" platform - mandatory
*New groups must be started on Freegle's preferred platform only - mandatory
*New groups must be able to add other platforms in the same way as existing groups - mandatory
*Groups must confirm once a year that they still wish to be affiliated with Freegle - mandatory


'''Do not allow messages asking to borrow items'''
Polls were held at the AGM 2017 [[http://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/AGM_2017_Minutes#3._MATTERS_ARISING]], resulting in the following:


'''Include the Freegle logo on the group homepage'''
*Freegle will introduce a deadline for getting rid of Yahoo Groups for the main Freegle groups (i.e. remove Yahoo from our list of viable platforms) - mandatory
*The time period for doing the above should be 12 months from the end of the AGM - mandatory
*We should not add Yahoo to any group from the end of the AGM - mandatory
(the plan for this can be found here - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1stGkGiub8IwYPs7keb0Q09GXbbuCVibHY7D9mROf5zY/edit)


'''Include a link to the Freegle website on the group homepage''' 
This means that all the requirements above are our basic shared values.  The mandatory requirements must be followed by all groups listed on the Freegle website, and groups are strongly encouraged to also adopt those that are highly recommended. (see note on poll results below)


'''Operate in a geographic area that is agreed with Freegle'''
[[Our Aims]] states the expectations for Freegle and Volunteers.


'''At least one moderator per group should be a member of Freegle Central (on minimum of special notices)'''
(Whether posts/items should be suitable for all ages was revisited by the Structure working group and the Reps - see note 1 below)


===Local Rules===


***Promote gifting items that are suitable for people of all ages'  47 Revist and reword Majority Vote***
Once admitted to Freegle, apart from adhering to what is agreed regarding the basic requirements, local Freegle groups are fully autonomous, independent and self governing.
So pretty much everything else is up to you and your members to decide. We should always remember that our groups are run for the benefit of your members - you will never please everyone, but a majority is good!  Think seriously before you impose local restrictions - one dilemma with restrictions is that if there are too many, members will not remember them, and it causes bad feeling if you keep rejecting posts.  It might be good to question the rules you have in place occasionally and ask yourself ‘is this helping keep stuff out of landfill?’.
Experienced moderators have compiled [[Best Practice]] which gives ideas on how you can review the way your Group is run.


Are non profit' (voted in previously by 97%) Y 83 MANDATORY
Advice can be obtained from the Mentor Team by emailing [mailto:mentors@ilovefreegle.org mentors@ilovefreegle.org ]


===Autonomy===


Pretty well everything else is up to you and your members to decide. We should always remember that our groups are run for the benefit of the members - you will never please everyone, but a majority is good! Think seriously before you impose local restrictions - one dilemma with restrictions is that if there are too many members will not remember them and it causes bad feeling to keep rejecting posts.
We use the word 'autonomy' quite a lot.  In Freegle terms this means:
*Advantage of being able to deal locally with local issues, adapting groups to local conditions (e.g rural or urban or innovation), and keeping our ethos of being a collective of like minded people who support grass roots initiatives in reuse of resources.
*Local groups must work to http://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/Basic_Requirements_of_a_Freegle_Group and http://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/Our Aims
*A group membership list belongs to that local group except when the group has been abandoned as per http://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/Abandoned_Groups_Procedure .
*Groups may choose to leave Freegle, or Freegle may choose to no longer be associated with a group, as per http://wiki.ilovefreegle.org/Disaffiliation_Procedure
*Otherwise local groups can be run as the volunteers see best for their community.
 
===Note on Poll Results and Interpretations===
 
The results of the [[January 2010 Poll]] have in practice been interpreted slightly differently to the actual outcome of the result until August 2010.  So the mandatory requirements of swapping, the logo, website link and membership of Freegle Central were seen to be highly recommended until the matter was discussed on Structure and brought to the attention of Central [[http://groups.yahoo.com/group/FreegleUK-Central/message/22582]]. 
 
===Geographic Area===
 
The interpretation of 'geographic area' has also been subsequently discussed.  Freegle agrees a core geographic area of operation for each group that is affiliated, but the catchment area the group chooses to operate with is a local decision.  Freegle will only agree one group for each core area as per the decision of Question 7 of the [[October 2009 Poll]].  The affiliation requirement is that it is highly recommended that the group operates in that agreed core geographic area.
 
===Changes to Affiliation Requirements===
 
In the [[January 2010 Poll]] it was agreed that in future affiliation requirements could only be voted as mandatory if the proposal got at least 66% of the vote.
 
The polls held in the 2016 AGM all gained a majority of at least 73%, so the additional requirements were all passed as mandatory.
 
===Note 1 Age Appropriate===
 
13th September 2013 - Structure Group recommended that an 'age appropriate' criteria shouldn't be adopted as an affiliation requirement, via message to Central http://groups.yahoo.com/group/FreegleUK-Central/message/41388
 
===Note 2 - Legal/Not Legal===
 
Items that might be considered legal or not legal (although not an exhaustive list) can be found via the page [[Specific Items]].
 
 
Back to Basic Information
[[Category: Historic documents]]<br>

Latest revision as of 10:42, 1 March 2022

THIS PAGE HAS BEEN SUPERSEDED BY Group Affiliation Requirements Policy BUT KEPT HERE AS HISTORICAL REFERENCE


Affiliation Requirements

The affiliation requirements for groups to be able to join and be part of the Freegle organisation were decided by polls of Freegle Volunteers. Now that we are an IPS, any changes will be by poll of Freegle Members.

The October 2009 Poll and January 2010 Poll, plus a Resolution carried at the AGM in 2019 [[1]] produced the current set of requirements for groups as follows:

  • All items offered or requested have to be free – mandatory
  • All items offered or requested have to be legal – mandatory
  • Selling of items is not allowed – mandatory
  • Be a non-profit group – mandatory
  • Swapping is not allowed - mandatory
  • Inclusion of the Freegle logo on the homepage- mandatory
  • Inclusion of a link to the Freegle website on the homepage - mandatory
  • All Freegle Volunteers will receive national announcements - mandatory
  • Do not allow messages asking to borrow items – highly recommended
  • Operate in a geographical area agreed with Freegle – highly recommended

Polls were held at the AGM 2016 [[2]], resulting in the following:

  • Freegle groups must use at least one "viable" platform - mandatory
  • New groups must be started on Freegle's preferred platform only - mandatory
  • New groups must be able to add other platforms in the same way as existing groups - mandatory
  • Groups must confirm once a year that they still wish to be affiliated with Freegle - mandatory

Polls were held at the AGM 2017 [[3]], resulting in the following:

  • Freegle will introduce a deadline for getting rid of Yahoo Groups for the main Freegle groups (i.e. remove Yahoo from our list of viable platforms) - mandatory
  • The time period for doing the above should be 12 months from the end of the AGM - mandatory
  • We should not add Yahoo to any group from the end of the AGM - mandatory

(the plan for this can be found here - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1stGkGiub8IwYPs7keb0Q09GXbbuCVibHY7D9mROf5zY/edit)

This means that all the requirements above are our basic shared values. The mandatory requirements must be followed by all groups listed on the Freegle website, and groups are strongly encouraged to also adopt those that are highly recommended. (see note on poll results below)

Our Aims states the expectations for Freegle and Volunteers.

(Whether posts/items should be suitable for all ages was revisited by the Structure working group and the Reps - see note 1 below)

Local Rules

Once admitted to Freegle, apart from adhering to what is agreed regarding the basic requirements, local Freegle groups are fully autonomous, independent and self governing. So pretty much everything else is up to you and your members to decide. We should always remember that our groups are run for the benefit of your members - you will never please everyone, but a majority is good! Think seriously before you impose local restrictions - one dilemma with restrictions is that if there are too many, members will not remember them, and it causes bad feeling if you keep rejecting posts. It might be good to question the rules you have in place occasionally and ask yourself ‘is this helping keep stuff out of landfill?’. Experienced moderators have compiled Best Practice which gives ideas on how you can review the way your Group is run.

Advice can be obtained from the Mentor Team by emailing mentors@ilovefreegle.org

Autonomy

We use the word 'autonomy' quite a lot. In Freegle terms this means:

Note on Poll Results and Interpretations

The results of the January 2010 Poll have in practice been interpreted slightly differently to the actual outcome of the result until August 2010. So the mandatory requirements of swapping, the logo, website link and membership of Freegle Central were seen to be highly recommended until the matter was discussed on Structure and brought to the attention of Central [[4]].

Geographic Area

The interpretation of 'geographic area' has also been subsequently discussed. Freegle agrees a core geographic area of operation for each group that is affiliated, but the catchment area the group chooses to operate with is a local decision. Freegle will only agree one group for each core area as per the decision of Question 7 of the October 2009 Poll. The affiliation requirement is that it is highly recommended that the group operates in that agreed core geographic area.

Changes to Affiliation Requirements

In the January 2010 Poll it was agreed that in future affiliation requirements could only be voted as mandatory if the proposal got at least 66% of the vote.

The polls held in the 2016 AGM all gained a majority of at least 73%, so the additional requirements were all passed as mandatory.

Note 1 Age Appropriate

13th September 2013 - Structure Group recommended that an 'age appropriate' criteria shouldn't be adopted as an affiliation requirement, via message to Central http://groups.yahoo.com/group/FreegleUK-Central/message/41388

Note 2 - Legal/Not Legal

Items that might be considered legal or not legal (although not an exhaustive list) can be found via the page Specific Items.


Back to Basic Information